Hartford LTD denials, terminations and appeals
Hartford Long-Term Disability Lawyers for Denied and Terminated Claims
If your Hartford LTD claim was denied or your benefits were terminated, the next few months decide your case. For most employer plans, the appeal you file with Hartford becomes the record a federal judge reviews later. We build that record with you, hold Hartford to ERISA's deadlines, and take the claim to federal court when Hartford will not pay.
- Hartford long-term disability attorneys for ERISA and individual policies, nationwide
- From the first denial letter through federal litigation
- Free, confidential case review
Last reviewed
Start your Hartford claim review
Free and confidential. An attorney-led team reviews every request.
Why Hartford denies or terminates long-term disability claims
Hartford Life and Accident Insurance Company insures and administers long-term disability coverage for many employers. The reasons it gives for a denial tend to repeat. Knowing which one appears in your letter tells you what evidence the appeal has to supply.
The 24-month switch to "any occupation"
Many Hartford policies pay for the first 24 months if you cannot do your own job, then require proof that you cannot do any job you are qualified for. Terminations cluster at that change. Hartford often relies on an employability or transferable skills analysis that lists jobs on paper. A strong appeal answers it with vocational evidence that reflects your real restrictions.
Hartford paper reviews and independent medical exams
Hartford commonly sends files to physicians who review records without examining you, or schedules an independent medical exam. When their opinion conflicts with your treating doctors, the appeal should explain why the treating opinion is better supported and fix any gaps the reviewer pointed to.
"No objective evidence" for pain, fatigue or cognitive symptoms
Conditions such as fibromyalgia, long COVID, chronic fatigue, migraine and post-concussion syndrome do not always appear on imaging. A functional capacity evaluation, neuropsychological testing and detailed treating-provider narratives can turn symptoms into measured limits.
Hartford surveillance and social media
Hartford may use video surveillance or public social media posts to argue you are more active than reported. A few minutes of activity rarely shows the ability to work full time, but the appeal has to address it directly.
The 24-month mental health limitation
Many group policies cap benefits for mental or nervous conditions, and sometimes for self-reported symptoms, at 24 months. How your condition is characterized can decide whether that limit applies at all.
Social Security offsets and overpayment demands
Hartford policies usually reduce LTD benefits by Social Security Disability benefits and may require you to apply. When SSDI pays retroactively, Hartford may demand repayment. An SSDI approval is also evidence of disability that Hartford must address.
Deadlines and procedure
ERISA regulations set deadlines for Hartford as well as for you. Missing information in a denial letter, an appeal decided late, or a new reason raised for the first time on appeal can all matter in court.
Your Hartford disability appeal is the case
Most long-term disability plans offered through an employer are governed by ERISA, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act. Before you can sue, you normally must appeal to Hartford. In many courts the judge then reviews only what was in Hartford's claim file when it decided the appeal. New evidence offered after that point is often excluded.
That makes the administrative appeal the most important stage of a Hartford LTD claim. We request the complete claim file and policy, identify every reason Hartford gave, and submit the medical, functional and vocational evidence that answers each one. Then we track Hartford's decision deadline so a late decision is documented.
Free case review
Tell us what happened. We review the denial or termination letter and explain the deadlines that apply to you.
Claim file and policy
We request the full Hartford claim file, including internal notes, reviewer reports, surveillance and the governing plan documents. ERISA entitles you to these at no charge.
Build the record
We work with your doctors on narrative reports and gather functional testing, vocational analysis and medical literature that fit your policy's definition of disability.
File the appeal and hold Hartford to the clock
Hartford generally has 45 days to decide an ERISA disability appeal, plus one 45-day extension if it gives written notice of special circumstances. We document every date.
Federal lawsuit if Hartford still says no
If Hartford upholds the denial, we can file suit in federal court under ERISA Section 502(a)(1)(B) to recover benefits.
Estimate your Hartford disability appeal deadline
ERISA plans must give you at least 180 days to appeal a disability denial. Enter the date you received Hartford's letter to see an estimate. Your letter and plan control, and some plans or state laws differ, so confirm the exact date with us.
This estimate is general information, not legal advice, and it may be wrong for you. It simply counts 180 calendar days from the date you enter. Your real deadline depends on your plan, your denial letter, when you actually received it, and the law that applies, and it may be earlier. Do not rely on this tool to decide when to act. Confirm your deadline with an attorney right away.
Estimate only. Not legal advice. Your actual deadline may be different, including earlier.
Have us confirm my deadlinePublic court decisions
Hartford disability lawsuit decisions that sent Hartford back
Hartford does not always win in court. These public decisions, handled by other lawyers, show what judges look for when they review a Hartford disability decision.
Butter v. Hartford Life & Accident Insurance Co.
816 F. Supp. 3d 223 (D. Mass. 2026) · U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts
Even under the deferential abuse-of-discretion standard, the court found Hartford's termination of long-term disability benefits was not supported by substantial evidence and did not meaningfully engage with the medical evidence supporting disability. The court denied both sides' motions and sent the claim back to Hartford for a new review.
Hartford has to grapple with the evidence you submit, not just cite its own reviewers.
Shupe v. Hartford Life & Accident Insurance Co.
19 F.4th 697 (4th Cir. 2021) · U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Hartford had paid a former executive sous chef with chronic osteomyelitis, degenerative disc disease and spinal stenosis since 2004 before terminating his benefits. The Fourth Circuit found the evaluations and medical history uniformly showed he could not work full-time sedentary jobs, called Hartford's contrary assessment an outlier, and directed that he be reinstated to the plan.
Long-paid claims can be defended when the full medical history is in the record.
Montour v. Hartford Life & Accident Insurance Co.
588 F.3d 623 (9th Cir. 2009) · U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
The Ninth Circuit held that Hartford's conflict of interest as both claim decision-maker and payer too heavily influenced its termination of long-term disability benefits. Hartford's reviewers had not addressed the Social Security Administration's contrary disability finding. The court reversed and remanded for an order reinstating benefits.
A Social Security Disability award is evidence Hartford must confront.
McQuillin v. Hartford Life & Accident Insurance Co.
36 F.4th 416 (2d Cir. 2022) · U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
Hartford did not finally decide the claimant's administrative appeal within the 45 days allowed by ERISA regulations. The Second Circuit held his remedies were deemed exhausted, so he could proceed in federal court, and reversed the dismissal of his long-term disability suit.
Hartford's appeal deadlines are enforceable. Keep track of the dates.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The court decisions described on this page are public rulings involving other law firms and claimants; they are not Feden Law Group results and are included to explain how courts review Hartford disability decisions.
Why claimants bring Hartford cases to Feden Law Group
Disability claims are the practice
We handle ERISA and individual disability claims from the first denial through federal litigation, not as a side line to other work.
Nationwide, in federal court
ERISA benefit claims are federal, so we can help with a Hartford plan wherever you live or worked.
Built for the record
We prepare every appeal as if a federal judge will read it, because one may.
Guidance even if we are not the fit
If your situation needs a different kind of lawyer, we tell you and point you toward help.
Hartford long-term disability questions
Hartford denied my long-term disability claim. What now?
Write down the date you received the letter and calendar your appeal deadline. Ask Hartford in writing for your complete claim file and the plan documents, which ERISA requires it to provide free of charge. Avoid filing a short appeal letter on your own. In many cases the appeal record is the only evidence a court will consider later.
How long do I have to appeal a Hartford LTD denial?
For ERISA-governed employer plans, federal regulations give you at least 180 days after you receive the denial to file an administrative appeal. Your denial letter should state the deadline. Individual policies and some government or church plans follow different rules.
How long does Hartford have to decide my disability appeal?
Under the ERISA claims regulation, Hartford generally must decide a disability appeal within 45 days, with one additional 45-day extension if it notifies you in writing of special circumstances before the first period ends. In McQuillin v. Hartford, the Second Circuit held that a claimant whose appeal was not decided in time could go straight to federal court.
Hartford says I can work "any occupation" after 24 months. Can I challenge that?
Yes. The change in definition does not mean your condition improved. Hartford must still show, based on your actual restrictions, education and experience, that there are occupations you can perform. Vocational evidence and updated treating-provider opinions are often the answer.
Can Hartford ignore my Social Security Disability approval?
Hartford is not bound by a Social Security decision, but courts expect it to address one, especially when Hartford encouraged you to apply and benefited from the offset. In Montour v. Hartford, the Ninth Circuit faulted Hartford's reviewers for failing to discuss the SSA's finding.
My disability coverage used to be with Aetna. Does that matter?
Hartford acquired Aetna's U.S. group life and disability business in 2017, so many claims that began under Aetna-branded coverage are now administered by Hartford. The plan documents still control, and we review both the original policy and any later changes.
How long do I have to sue Hartford for long-term disability benefits?
It depends on your plan. Many Hartford policies set a contractual limit, often measured from when proof of loss was due rather than from the final appeal decision. In Heimeshoff v. Hartford (2013), the U.S. Supreme Court enforced a three-year limit of that kind. Check your plan early.
What does it cost to talk to a Hartford disability lawyer?
The consultation is free. If we can take your case, we explain the fee arrangement in writing before you hire us.
Do you handle Hartford disability claims in my state?
We handle Hartford claims under ERISA employer plans nationwide because they are governed by federal law. Individual policies and non-ERISA plans can involve state law; we will tell you how your state affects the claim.
Disability claims against other insurers
Hartford said no. That is not the final word.
Tell us where your claim stands. The review is free.
Feden Law Group PLLC · (267) 234-7465 · nfeden@fedenlawgroup.com
Attorney Advertising. Responsible attorney: Nicholas Feden.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The court decisions described on this page are public rulings involving other law firms and claimants; they are not Feden Law Group results and are included to explain how courts review Hartford disability decisions.
This page provides general information, not legal advice for your situation. Contacting us or submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send medical records, Social Security numbers, or other confidential documents until we confirm we can represent you.
The Hartford and related names are trademarks of their owners. Feden Law Group PLLC is not affiliated with The Hartford.